All the glory of existence, the realm of Ahura Mazda, the uncreated spirit, wholly wise, benevolent and good, shines as far as the eye can see. All that is holy and beautiful is Ahura’s domain, and the soul of which the god is made, permeates through all of us. All that is rotting, impure, and foul, angra mainyu rules. Death, decay, and evil are all temporary victories of Angra Mainyu in the material plane. Corrupting our spirits, he infects material things including plants, animals and human beings, rivers, wells, lakes and air. Material things succumb to corruption.
Outsmarting the harbingers of doom, Zoroastrians neither bury nor cremate their dead, as they immediately have become impure by the assaults of evil spirits. One can only do one thing in case of death: leave the body outside, isolated, letting it decay. Only untouched and undisturbed by susceptible living people, can the corruption safely be disposed of. According to the Avestas and other scriptures, the only way to effectively isolate a body so as to not become corrupted, is to refrain from touching it. We must protect that which is beautiful and sacred. This impulse to revere life and beauty as goodness, occurs in religious traditions globally. Without evidence to the contrary, humanity’s initial, or natural, theories describe creation as beautiful and complicated. As the march of human progress continues unceasingly, three clear problems emerge in the evolution of religion.
- Metaphysical evolutions from different inherited traditions, particularly around death, end at mutually exclusive destinations.
- Religious expression mirrors the relationship of humanity with its surrounding environment, both socially and geographically. The relationship is moderated by taboos.
- A movement towards the abstract as a response to increasing knowledge and competition in the religious domain pushes them deeper into metaphysics and abstractions.
An excellent case study for the development of religions in society due to the clarity of its teleology. In the Zoroastrian dichotomy of Gods, Angra Mainyu and Ahura Mazda, we find the eternal struggle between good and evil. Between all that is pure, and all that is corrupted. The never ending celestial battle arises from the pages of their holy books, showing the titanic struggle of death against life, the will to exist battling the dreaded end. Although the good and evil dichotomy exists in many religions, few are willing to take such a strong stand on the existence of a cosmic good and evil. Early religious injunctions order us to maintain the sanctity of our human refuge. To prevent the corruption from spreading into the beautiful, to keep it from being infused with evil.
Death. The sacred and the profane merge around this inescapable human experience with ritualistic relevance. Fire is the sacred symbol of Ahura Mazda for the Zoroastrians. Fire does not cleanse the corrupted impurities of the body, instead, the fire is contaminated and rendered impure by burning a corpse. The same goes for earth and water. Touching a corpse on purpose can lead to corruption. You can safely dispose of a corpse by leaving them in the tower of silence. This tower, open topped, offers access to the vultures and crows, wolves and dogs to come and gorge themselves on the impure flesh. The cosmic order, the most sanctified and holy truth: the fire must not be corrupted.
The Rigveda, the oldest of the sacred books of Hinduism, talks about the origin of the universe in which the Nāsadīya Sūkta describes the deathless, breathless immortality of the early universe. Breath within the hindu traditions, correlates with life, the very word for breath (prāṇa) meaning “life force”. Hindu death rituals invert the Zoroastrian one. Fire is purification, melting the corruption of life and attachments away, ending in permanent and ungraspable anonymity.
The evolution of these two traditions lead to different, mutually exclusive, destinations. Either bodily remains corrupt fire, or the fire purifies the soul from the body. Skillfully evading the question of the nature of religion (what does, or does not, constitute a religion), all religions aim at explaining fundamental truths about the nature of the universe. The “belief” stooling religion, means that what you believe in, is accurate. Solving the abstract puzzle of conflicting realities, the iron age saw rapid expansion in the domain of metaphysics.
Building religious belief depends structurally on the relationship of the human community with its surroundings. Culture trumps religion, every time. Early naturalistic religions emphasize similar things, the souls, power, and complexity of the natural world. The stones harbor more than meets the eye, the owl brings wisdom and sees into the unknown. The cultivation of the soils and the segregation of humans into villages and cities distorts this old relationship. The domination of the natural world bleeds into religious life. Reverence becomes stewardship, complexity becomes accountancy. The metaphysical tradition influences the extent and domains that this bleeds into. The sense of compassion in the vedas for animals extends from large mammals all the way to insects. Nature is part of divinity in the vedas, changing the way that religious adherents of the vedas treat animal life. The relation to their environment builds understanding and respect for the natural environment. Cultural practices, over time, get codified into religious laws, virtues, sins, and my favorite, taboos. Social environments contain the power to shape human behavior by telling you off. Taboos, if not yet codified into law and not broken by prominent members of the community, form a boundary for what behavior is acceptable. Practicing what the community preaches.
To learn more about the vedas, here’s my source: https://www.hinduscriptures.in/vedic-lifestyle/customs-and-traditions/nature-worship/significance-of-animals-a-vedic-perspective.
Religious traditions move, just like people move. Taboos and behaviors collide when people migrate and mix, but what happens when confronted with competing views of what you deem (w)holy accurate? How do religions deal with the coming of competing or alternative views?
The very existence of a competing world view, acts as an evolutionary pressure.
Like the population dynamics of genetic variance or the basic reproduction number in epidemiology, religions can spread and infect different populations. The r-value, the rate at which it spreads, dependent on a large set of variables and confounders, are far beyond the scope of this essay. One important factor, however, are the taboos of certain religious claims. The apocryphal story of the Russian conversion to christianity emphasizes the importance of taboo on spreading religions. The islamic delegates told the Russians they had a taboo on eating pork or drinking liquor, so the Russians opted for christianity instead. Culture trumps religion, most of the time. More pertinent to the evolution of religion in this essay: metaphysics. Digging deeper into the responses, not of the people or the cultural practices and taboos, but to the clerics and theologians building dogma or scriptural interpretations. Out of infinite possible responses, clerical answers to competing religions broadly fall into two categories:
- Double down and maintain strict orthodoxy. Revert to the text, do not change any interpretation, and battle the heathens with fire, sword, and pen.
- Change your claims. Hide in metaphysics and hermeneutics. Add layers of complexity to move it away from the original structure and intent of the religion.
The first kind, generally the first response, offers stability and mental well being. It is the first response when the power dynamic favors the old interpretation. Conserve the old order and persecute the heretic, easy to do when you hold the levers of power and command the armies. Examples include the inquisition and the rise of Cartesian philosophy. The old institutions used fire and sword to battle the new ways of thinking, defending Aristotelianism and the miracles claimed by revealed religion. Religious innovations and new cults fall in this category as well. Jesus, Mohammed, and quite a few other metaphysical innovators battled conservative forces in their time.
When an area, conquered by zealots from another religion, experiences a foreign administration and different metaphysical order, the power dynamic doesn’t favor traditional religious interpretations. How do you deal with the subservience dealt to you by your godly patrons? The ruling clerics of this foreign religion disagree with your interpretation, and it seems like the god(s) have abandoned your faith. Simple, change the claims.
Stop promoting religious imagery, the way that the culture proscribed, such as the rise of iconoclasm in the Eastern Roman Empire. Change religious interpretation of metaphysical truths. Silently convinced, the community shifts interpretations, bringing a revolution in thought, and often, leadership. Examples include the development of Abrahamic religions in response to Hellenistic philosophy and the responses of dharmic religions to charvaka.
The easiest metaphysical retreat, spurred on by a competing view within a subservient power dynamic: the nature of god in abrahamic religions. Originally, god is a great ape, like us (genesis 1:26 and 1:27; 2 Corinthians 4:4; etc.). With Roman Conquest, Hellenic philosophy, and Zoroastrian religion entering the scene, old school interpretations of heaven and God run into competing claims for reality. Before the coming of the Romans, the Babylonian exile, and the contact with philosophers, the fall of humanity was clear. By choosing the material pleasures, God casts humanity from the heavens, to suffer the corruption of the earth. We were in the heavenly domain, a physical place. Exodus 24:10 describes a pavement made of sapphire or lapis lazuli.[3] Ezekiel 1 describes a throne room made of angels and God’s throne being seated on a flying angel. Isaiah 6 describes an altar standing before God’s throne. 2 Chronicles 18 and 1 Kings 22 describe angels to the right and the left of God. J Edward Wright, to whom this essay owes a lot (the early history of heaven), describes how early Judaic and Christian religion linked the experience of heaven to direct divine presence or reward. Later conceptions tended to be more abstract, institutionalized, and influenced by theological developments and philosophical reasoning. Competing views on reality leading to an evolutionary pressure.
The same goes for the nature of God. St Augustine of hippo, a converted manichean, wrestles with platonism, the existence of good and evil, and the omnipotent nature of god. Formulating the now standard interpretation of god as eternal, omnipotent, and most importantly: transcendent. Multiple centuries of theological development saw the final reconciliation of the philosophical, reasoned “unmoved mover”, and the Judaic creator and law giver. God had an active role, smiting, genociding, and bringing plagues. Over time, competing claims turned god into a fine tuner, the universe suddenly existed without universal mover. The god of negation, that which cannot be captured into human words. The greatest thing someone can imagine, with no evidence of its existence. The metaphysics shifts and defends further and further out claims, until eventually, none will be left.
None, except for the people who maintained the strict taboos, adhered to the orthodoxy, experienced a favorable power dynamic in society, and resisted conquest from other interpretations.
Leave a Reply